Pages

Sunday, February 24, 2013

Investing Advice for Oldsters ... Buy Low and Sell High

Will Rogers said that the key to successful investing is to buy low and sell high. No kidding.

Knowing when to do so is the missing piece of the buy low-sell high puzzle. That said, it's not all that difficult to do and oldsters need to look at it carefully these days.

How you can be a smart market timer is subtitled 'To get top dollar, buy, reinvest, rebalance and hold:'

"Investors complain a lot about the performance of their mutual funds, but they’d be a lot happier and do better financially if they simply got the same results as those funds earn.

Instead, a new study from investment researcher Morningstar Inc. shows that investors habitually get the worst from their funds, earning lower returns than the investment vehicles they are buying.

You don’t have to settle for that.

To see why, consider the latest research from Russel Kinnel, Morningstar’s director of fund research, who compared a straight average of fund returns to an asset- or dollar-weighted average investor return.

Dollar-weighted returns are designed to show a fund’s results based on when money moves in or out; they show if investors are chasing performance, buying funds only after a big runup or losing faith and selling before a rebound.

Kinnel found that over the decade ended in 2012, the average stock fund returned 7.05% annually, but the average investor netted 6.1%. . . .

Time and money

Giving into fear or greed is the root cause here, but investors may not recognize that their behavior contributes to the shortfall.

“Mutual funds are long-term investments and the way to get a superior return is to hold it for a long time,” said Kinnel. “It used to be that people made decisions based on the fund’s returns over the last few years. Now it seems to be that they make decisions based on the 24-hour news cycle and what they just heard. Either way, they’re making bad decisions.”

Here’s how that plays out.

The typical investor buys funds only after a strong run of good results, thus they are buying high. Their money did not get that positive performance stretch, however; they only get what happens next. If the fund slows or falters, the fund’s performance may still be positive but the investor hasn’t really experienced those gains.

If the investor sells when the fund falters, they not only lock in a loss or poor results, but they also go a bit insane, repeating the process again — buying another fund that has been hot — but expecting different results.

Here’s how to get the performance close to what the fund provides: You must reinvest dividends and distributions and make additional deposits either regularly or when the fund seems undervalued, rather than when it has made the account statement look fat.

“Macro timing is bad for people because they fool themselves into thinking they can outsmart the market,” Kinnel said. “They hear some news or see some hot numbers and they don’t realize that in jumping on this bandwagon, what they are saying is ‘There’s a lot more good news coming, even though I don’t know anything more than anyone else about this.’”

It’s important to recognize that lackluster dollar-weighted returns are caused by the individual investor, not the fund, and that they happen to people who own good funds.

“The one way you can wreck a diversified portfolio of solid, low-cost mutual funds is by doing a lot of market calls,” Kinnel said. . . .

Balance and rebalance

Avoiding the problem involves striking an appropriate balance between fear and greed — and not acting on either.

In fact, the best way to ensure performance that is close to what the fund delivers is to rebalance a portfolio. . . .

Experts about investor behavior note that investors don’t need to ignore human nature, but rather have to understand it."

Summing Up

Knowing a little about our all too human nature is the key to investing.

We experience much more pain when stock prices fall than we experience pleasure when the market rises. That's just the way we're wired.

Accordingly, knowing ourselves and our tendencies is essential if we want to become successful long term investors, and we should all want that.

To state the obvious, a little means a lot in investing. Each 1%, up or down, will add up to a whole lot over a lifetime of saving and investing.

Just the difference of earning 2% less on average annually, whether from paying commissions, trading costs, or being out of the market at the wrong time, will cause the individual individual at retirement to have 50% of what he would have had had he earned that 2% on average. That's the rule of 72 at work again.

That said, when we approach oldster status, it's a good idea to take some gains off the table and not subject ourselves to the need to sell when prices are low.

It's all about knowing yourself and your financial needs. For those who have enough income, whether from dividends, earnings, Social Security or otherwise, staying the course through thick and thin is not a bad idea.

For all other oldsters and near oldsters, however, it's best to have some cash on hand in order not to have to sell when market surprises hit, which they do with uncanny but predictably unpredictable regularity.

That's my take.

Thanks. Bob.


Saturday, February 23, 2013

How "Progressives" Plan to Keep Youth Unemployment High, Economic Growth Low and Thereby Improve Their Chances for Retaking the House in 2014

Here's my tongue-in-cheek assessment of the politics taking place today in America. Or maybe it's not so tongue-in-cheek at that. You be the judge.

The "progressives have" a masterful plan to keep youth unemployment high, economic growth weak and in the process enhance their chances to retake control of the House of Representatives in 2014. At least it seems that way to me. Otherwise I have no clue why they're doing what they're doing.

(1) Youth unemployment is high and going higher if President Obama's proposal to raise the minimum wage to $9 per hour is enacted. In all likelihood it won't be, but at least he can say he tried. That helps with the youth vote. And if somehow it does pass Congressional muster, it won't DIRECTLY harm the government deficit anyway, he reasons. Employers will get stuck with the bill instead of the government, and young people won't get hired anyway.

(2) The payroll tax increased by 2% January 1st. That will discourage consumer spending and raise more money to keep the oldsters voting for the "progressives" as the money will be used to protect Social Security benefits. Although fewer hires will result, the government deficit won't be negatively impacted --- at least not directly.

(3) Now ObamaCare will require small employers to enroll low wage employees in the government's new health care plan in 2014. That means employees who work more than 30 hours per week at a fast food retaurant, as an example, will be required to get health insurance or their employer will have to pay a $2,000 penalty for each such employee not covered. This applies to companies that have more than 50 employees and for any employee who works more than 30 hours weekly.

ObamaCare and the '29ers' is subtitled 'How the new mandates are already reducing full-time employment:'

"Here's a trend you'll be reading more about: part-time "job sharing," not only within firms but across different businesses.

It's already happening across the country at fast-food restaurants, as employers try to avoid being punished by the Affordable Care Act. In some cases we've heard about, a local McDonalds has hired employees to operate the cash register or flip burgers for 20 hours a week and then the workers head to the nearby Burger King or Wendy's to log another 20 hours. Other employees take the opposite shifts.

 

image

Welcome to the strange new world of small-business hiring under ObamaCare. The law requires firms with 50 or more "full-time equivalent workers" to offer health plans to employees who work more than 30 hours a week. (The law says "equivalent" because two 15 hour a week workers equal one full-time worker.) Employers that pass the 50-employee threshold and don't offer insurance face a $2,000 penalty for each uncovered worker beyond 30 employees. So by hiring the 50th worker, the firm pays a penalty on the previous 20 as well.


These employment cliffs are especially perverse economic incentives. Thousands of employers will face a $40,000 penalty if they dare expand and hire a 50th worker. The law is effectively a $2,000 tax on each additional hire after that, so to move to 60 workers costs $60,000.

A 2011 Hudson Institute study estimates that this insurance mandate will cost the franchise industry $6.4 billion and put 3.2 million jobs "at risk." The insurance mandate is so onerous for small firms that Stephen Caldeira, president of the International Franchise Association, predicts that "Many stores will have to cut worker hours out of necessity. It could be the difference between staying in business or going out of business." . . .

Because other federal employment regulations also kick in when a firm crosses the 50 worker threshold, employers are starting to cap payrolls at 49 full-time workers. These firms have come to be known as "49ers." Businesses that hire young and lower-skilled workers are also starting to put a ceiling on the work week of below 30 hours. These firms are the new "29ers." Part-time workers don't have to be offered insurance under ObamaCare.

The mandate to offer health insurance doesn't take effect until 2014, but the "measurement period" used by the feds to determine a firm's average number of full-time employees started last month. So the cutbacks and employment dodges are underway.

The savings from restricting hours worked can be enormous. If a company with 50 employees hires a new worker for $12 an hour for 29 hours a week, there is no health insurance requirement. But suppose that worker moves to 30 hours a week. This triggers the $2,000 federal penalty. So to get 50 more hours of work a year from that employee, the extra cost to the employer rises to about $52 an hour—the $12 salary and the ObamaCare tax of what works out to be $40 an hour.
image 

Moving to 33 hours a week costs the employer about $10 an hour more in ObamaCare tax. Look for fewer 30-35 hour-a-week jobs. The law that was sold as a way to help business and workers is thus yanking a few more rungs from the ladder of economic upward mobility.

Many franchisees of Burger King, McDonalds, Red Lobster, KFC, Dunkin' Donuts and Taco Bell have started to cut back on full-time employment, though many are terrified to talk on the record. Activist groups have organized boycotts against Darden Restaurants, which owns Olive Garden and Red Lobster, for daring to publicly criticize ObamaCare. It's safer to quietly dodge the new costs and avoid becoming a political target.

But the damage won't be limited to franchisees or restaurants. A 2012 survey of employers by the Mercer consulting firm found that 67% of retail and wholesale firms that don't offer insurance coverage today "are more inclined to change their workforce strategy so that fewer employees meet that [30 hour a week] threshold." This week Nigel Travis, the CEO of Dunkin' Donuts, asked Congress to change the health law's definition of full-time to 40 hours a week from 30 hours so worker hours won't have to be cut.

The timing of all this couldn't be worse. Involuntary part-time U.S. employment is already near a record high. The latest Department of Labor employment survey counts roughly eight million Americans who want a full-time job but are stuck in a part-time holding pattern. That number is down only 520,000 since January 2010 and it is 309,000 higher than last March. (See the nearby chart.) And now comes ObamaCare to increase the incentive for employers to hire only part-time workers.

Democrats who thought they were doing workers a favor by mandating health coverage can't seem to understand that it doesn't help workers to give them health care if they can't get a full-time job that pays the rest of their bills."

Summing Up

Throw in the fear mongering associated with sequestration and the "progressives" have virtually guaranteed that the economy will stay weak, consumers will remain on the sidelines and hiring the youth by small employers will be avoided to the fullest extent possible.

This then will enable the progressives to argue that even more government spending is required and that the rich and others who actually have full time jobs need to pay more in taxes so the government can provide additional benefits to support the part timers and the youth who remain unemployed. Brilliant!

And lest we forget, progressives will also reason that the oldsters who vote in large numbers won't have their benefits in any way negatively impacted either. That should keep them in a good frame of mind for voting, too.

And that should do it. Game over. Yes, the 2014 elections are shaping up nicely for the "progressives," or so it seems to them.

Will the rest of We the People ever wise up? Well, we haven't yet.

We sure do live in interesting times.

Thanks. Bob.

Sequestration Games ... Heads President Obama Wins; Tails Americans Lose

President Obama seems to be talking against allowing the sequester to take effect while planning to capitalize on it politically at the same time.

It seems to be a heads-I-win, tails-you-lose approach to defeat his political adversaries, the Republicans.

The American people, as usual, are bystanders and on the receiving end of being 'sold' a bunch of crapola by the President and the rest of the Washington based political aristocracy.

Happily, however, most of We the People seem to be seeing the reality of what's happening more clearly this time. It's more political theater.

Obama Blame Games summarizes the sequestration situation thusly:

"Republican leaders suspect that President Obama's tirade against the sequester spending cuts may be motivated by a desire to blame GOP lawmakers for any economic slowdown in the spring or summer.

It's a tactic Mr. Obama has used before. For three years he blamed George W. Bush for an anemic recovery. He said the tepid economy at the start of 2012 resulted from Republicans "playing games" on the debt ceiling in 2011. He blamed the negative economic growth numbers in the fourth quarter of 2012 on "bad decisions in Washington," by which he meant Republicans in Congress who insisted on budget cuts that caused a decline in government expenditures.

On Thursday Mr. Obama repeated the doomsday rhetoric from his Tuesday press conference. The sequester cuts, he warned, will have a "negative effect on the overall economy. It's going to put hundreds of thousands of jobs at risk." He added that Republicans can't see the obvious solution—higher taxes, of course—"that is right in front of them."

The suspicion is that Mr. Obama is hedging his bets on an economy that continues to tread water. . . . So while the housing sector is currently improving, consumer spending and business investment is still weak. And Wal-Mart—the largest retailer in the world—reported a dismal start to February sales. Also, gas prices are up. The Obama tax increases may be starting to bite.

"We think U.S. earnings and GDP will come up short of current high expectations," writes economist David Malpass of Encima Capital, "and the March 1 sequester will be used as a scapegoat for weakness." He adds that it may be Mr. Obama's hard line on taxes that is bearish. "We expect the sequester to proceed," he tells his clients. "President Obama probably won't offer substitute spending cuts—it would be a bullish move to the center if he did."

It may also be a smart move politically for Mr. Obama, whose poll numbers have bumped up since the election. If the economy picks up speed, he undoubtedly gets the credit. If it stalls out, it's Republican hard-liners who are to blame."

Summing Up

Placing some control on runaway wasteful government spending would be a good thing, regardless of the motivation behind doing it.

So thank you for that, President Obama.

Now please find some more ways to stop this wasteful spending debacle and reduce the size of government, even though that's not in your "progressive" playbook.

Who says unintended consequences are always a bad thing? Not I.

Thanks. Bob.

Sequestration is Coming ... Congress and the White House are Fools

Sequestration is the best of the bad choices available for cutting spending in Washington. At least it seems that way to most Americans. I agree.

Notable & Quotable is subtitled 'Pollster Scott Rasmussen on why voters aren't rebelling against the sequester:'

"Pollster Scott Rasmussen writing at RealClearPolitics, Feb. 22:

There's a panic bubbling to the surface in Washington, D.C. It's being brought about by the so-called sequester, scheduled to take effect next Friday, March 1. The sequester, a series of automatic across-the-board spending reductions, is a gimmick the politicians came up with in 2011 to force themselves to reach some kind of long-term deficit-reduction deal.

The expectation was that voters would rise up and protest the automatic spending cuts with such vehemence that it would force Republicans and Democrats to work together. But it hasn't happened. In fact, just 36 percent of voters want Congress and the president to stop the automatic cuts.

As a result, the White House and many media organizations have been trying to raise the alarm. . . .

Still, the voters haven't come around. The president proposed replacing the across-the-board spending cuts with a combination of tax hikes and specific spending cuts. Only 39 percent favor that proposal. Forty-two percent oppose it and prefer the automatic spending cuts instead.

This is not to suggest that the automatic spending cuts are popular. They're not. When the sequester gimmick was first proposed, just 29 percent thought it would be a good idea to have such arbitrary cuts implemented. But after watching the nation's elected politicians perform for the past year and a half, while voters still see the automatic cuts as bad policy, they see them as less bad than the other options."

Summing Up

While the President hits the "campaign trail" again next week, the American people seem to have better things to do than listen to all the fear mongering about spending more than last year but less than government otherwise would spend.

In other words, the cuts aren't even cuts. They're just lower raises.

Only in "progressive" America does crapola like this get treated like news.

We the People get it now. It's the political aristocracy that needs awakening.

Maybe someday that will happen. But not yet.

Thanks. Bob.

U.S. Health Care Costs Are a Chaotic Mess and Completely Out of Control, Too ... Medicare v. Private Insurance Charges and Reimbursement Rates Are Totally Different ... Complete Chaos is the Result

Overview of the U.S. Health Care Chaotic Mess

The U.S. health care system is broken. It's also a government directed, favor granting, cronyism based non-market system with out-of-control costs and a secretive pricing mechanism that makes absolutely no sense.

It's also full of mystery about how things are priced and the third party payer model means essentially that nobody acts as an effective monitor on the cost, quality and delivery system. As a result, health care pricing is out of control.

While at first glance very few individual customers appear to have any of their own skin in the game, in fact all of We the People have our skin in the game. We can't afford to allow America's health care 'system' to continue its wasteful and largely unproductive crapshoot ways.

Not for profit hospitals earn more than for profit hospitals, although both earn outsized profits by overcharging through something called the 'chargemaster' pricing system. There is no effective market as Congress, hospitals, doctors, insurers, medical device makers, pharmaceutical companies and Medicare and Medicaid rules and regulations have combined to make the 'secret' system too costly for no good reason.

ObamaCare won't help make things better either (probably much worse, in fact), although this specific piece of legislation didn't have anything to do with creating the unaffordable health care mess in the first place. Congress and the medical profession and industry had screwed that up long ago.

All this has to change for the better, but it's not happening. Not at all.

U.S. Health Care Costs at a Glance

Health care costs are by far our nation's biggest financial problem in need of a solution.

And the American Medical Association is by far our nation's most powerful and unproductive labor union.

Hospitals, medical device makers and pharmaceutical companies are big parts of the problem too. Especially not-for-profit hospitals.

Meanwhile, American health care costs are by far the most expensive in the world.

The pricing system is a mysterious crapshoot which is rigged against the ultimate payers, including taxpayers and individual paying patients.

That's why oldsters like for Medicare to pay their health care bills. Its costs aren't at all apparent or important to them. At least not directly.

And now government has added to the high priced circus by enacting ObamaCare, which comes on top of all the bad things Congress has done with respect to health care over the previous several decades.

Unfortunately, much more heat than light has been shed on this entire health care mess in America. Until now, that is.

Time Magazine has published a comprehensive analysis of Medicare reimbursement rates compared to private insurance. In simple language, prices charged to individuals and their insurers for the exact same procuedures are far and away higher -- dramatically higher -- than comparable charges paid by the Medicare system. Our third party based health care pricing, cost, delivery and overall reimbursement system is completely broken, in other words.

Doctors and hospitals are using Medicare to drive high volume and revenue per transaction and customer (Wal-Mart pricing model) in exchange for comparatively 'low' fees and then sticking the non-Medicare private sector patients with dramatically higher fees for the same procedures (the Rolls Royce pricing model). When blended, the Medicare volume benefits and the non-Medicare pricing strategy make for a very lucrative health care industry.

Doctors, hospitals, drug companies and medical device makers all enjoy the rewards of a lucrative non-market based system which is sponsored and protected by the government rule makers. We the People get the shaft.

And as a result health care in America has become a very costly, unaffordable and out of control chaotic 'system.'

The Harsh Facts About Our Broken Health Care "System"

Make health care more like Medicare summarizes the just released longest article ever published by Time. I recommend that you take the time to read the entire article. And if you don't want to read it all, read the first few pages and then skip over to the last few pages. You'll be glad you did.

In any event, the Time story is both very educational and a bit sickening as well. Here's the summary:

"Steve Brill, founder of Court TV and the magazines American Lawyer and Brill’s Content . . . is a go-big-or-go-home writer, fond of the long, meticulously reported piece. So it’s only fitting that his detailed critique of America’s out-of-control health-care spending, the cover story in this week’s issue of Time magazine, took seven months of research and clocks in at 36 pages . . . . And the epic article winds its way around an interesting thesis: While the steady growth of Medicare spending is a public-policy problem—along with Medicaid, Brill writes, it’s “what’s driving the federal deficit”—the health-care system would be in far worse shape if Medicare weren’t around.
Time Magazine
Decoding the health-care crisis, in 36 pages.

Central to Brill’s argument is a Health Care 101 explanation of how Medicare sets its reimbursement rates for medical procedures. “Medicare collects troves of data on what every type of treatment, test and other service costs hospitals to deliver,” he explains, factoring overhead, salaries and a multitude of other expenses – but not leaving room for much of a profit margin, if any.

Brill then offers several real-life examples demonstrating the huge spread between the Medicare reimbursement rates and the rates that hospitals and doctors try to charge to private insurers and patients paying out-of-pocket. A blood-protein test that Medicare reimburses at $13.94 gets billed at $199.50 to an uninsured 64-year-old; a stress test for the same patient gets marked up from the $554 Medicare rate to almost $8,000. Three CT scans for a slip-and-fall victim? Medicare would have paid about $825 in total; but a Connecticut hospital billed the patient $6,538.

Brill also points out the many ways in which Medicare fails to control costs: The system is constrained by law from using its buying power to negotiate lower prescription-drug prices, for example; and it lacks incentives that would keep patients from pursuing medical care they don’t need or keep physicians from “over-doctoring.” Doctors and hospitals have long complained that Medicare reimbursement rates don’t reflect their true costs, and while Brill thinks that some of this amounts to crying poor—citing examples of high hospital profit margins—he concedes that “no doctor could hope for anything approaching the income he or she deserves (and that will make future doctors want to practice) if 100% of their patients yielded anything close to the low rates Medicare pays.”

Still, Brill concludes that the our health-care system would be more efficient, and more affordable, if it were to become more like Medicare, with pricing that’s predictable and transparent. “Unless you are protected by Medicare, the health care market is not a market at all,” he concludes. “It’s a crapshoot. “ And at least for now, it’s a crapshoot that retirees can skip once they turn 65."

Summing Up

To repeat, I recommend that you take this opportunity to become more informed about our health care cost, pricing and reimbursement system. It's a mess and one that affects us all.

Health care is the biggest single financial issue facing America today.
 
Getting to a better reality by seeking the truth is always preferable to remaining ignorant (not to be confused with stupid) about important things affecting our individual lives and overall well being as a society.

So together let's seek that truth about health care in America, our nation's biggest financial problem and one which is desperately in need of a lasting and affordable comprehensive solution.

That solution can only come from transparency and an open and honest national conversation, which this article will help facilitate. Of that I'm certain.

Happy reading!

Thanks. Bob.

Friday, February 22, 2013

Birthdays ... George Washington's and My Dad's Too

My Dad would have been 100 years old yesterday. He died much too young at the age of 61 in 1974.

George Washington's birthday is today. He was born on February 22, 1732. He died December 14, 1799 at the age of 67.

Their birthdays remind me of a story I once heard about the difference between the way Americans and Europeans tend to view the past and the future. It bears repeating.

Think of two circles alongside each other, one small and one large.

The circles represent the importance of how a society's citizens view the past and the future, respectively.

Europeans put the small circle on the right and the large circle on the left.

America has the small circle on the left and the large circle on the right.

The left to right arrangement also symbolizes a timeline connecting the past and the future.

Europe lives in the past.

America lives for the future.

My Dad's name was Player Glenn Cook. Glenn is spelled with two "NNs."  It's of Irish origin, I'm told, and my guess is that somewhere back in time his ancestors earned their way to America and became cooks.

In any event, Dad's Dad was a railroader and both of his brothers were as well. Our small home town was a railroad hub for the Santa Fe, and both my older brother and I worked there during school breaks. We didn't grow up on the wrong side of the tracks, but we lived nearby.

Dad and Mom always heavily encouraged both my brother and me to go to college, so my guess is that's a big reason why we did. Both of us went on to earn graduate degrees and did well in our chosen careers.

Dad and Mom married during the Great Depression and didn't go to college. Mom didn't finish high school. They both worked hard all their adult lives (as an hourly paid distillery worker and an hourly paid grade school cafeteria leader) in order that my older brother and I would enjoy opportunities that they never had. They wanted us to have every chance to pursue and live the 'American Dream.'

Dad and Mom put the small circle on the left for sure. The big one on the right was for their kids.

George Washington's ancestors emigrated from England to Virginia. I don't have to tell you anything about his life story, so I won't even try. Being known as the "father of his country" perhaps says all that needs saying.

Accordingly, I'm quite certain that Mr. Washington put the small circle on the left as well.

So here's what makes me wonder about lots of things happening in America today. Why do so many of our political "leaders" want to emulate Europe? Why do they insist that the small circle belongs on the right? Why do they want us to become a European like social welfare state?

Didn't our ancestors come here from there in order to avoid that small circle on the right syndrome? Aren't we still destined to be 'the land of opportunity?' I think so.

So Happy 281st Birthday, President Washington and a belated 100th one to my Dad as well.

And thanks to both of you for everything you did for me.

And especially for putting the big circle on the right.

It's the future that matters most to our kids and grandkids. Thus, it's the future that matters most to us oldsters as well.

That's my take.

Thanks. Bob.

Public v. Private Sector TOTAL Compensation ... How Fair and How is It Determined

 Overview

There is a big difference between the absolute need for continuous and rapid improvements in private sector productivity and the general lack of any productivity gains in the public sector.

In my opinion, the difference in productivity gains between the private and public sectors is attributable to the system, and is not the result of the different capabilities of those individuals who work in the different sectors.

For example, earning an adequate profit for the company's investors is the fundamental cost of staying in business in the private sector. Accordingly, in the private sector the need to generate profits serves as a lid on uncontrolled compensation and other costs relative to prices. It's a price based costing world and if prices are too high relative to competition, the company goes bankrupt over time.

However, no such need for profitability exists in the non-price based costing model followed by the monopolistic public sector. There's no need to make profits, so there's no effective constraint on costs, including compensation. It's really that simple.

The system of capitalism, aka private sector competition, is all about disruptive market based competition --- improving upon the status quo by destroying the old way of doing things, taking risks, innovating and pursuing entrepreneurial endeavors. As opposed to merely working in the existing system, private sector leadership is required to contnuously work on the system to make beneficial changes to lower costs and improve the value of the goods and services offered for sale.

On the other hand, public sector employees work in a monopolistic and risk averse system where disruptive change is resisted and preserving the status quo is the main objective in the work place. Accordingly, risk taking, innovation and productivity enhancing entrepreneurial efforts are largely missing in the public arena. It's the way the system works.

Comparing Private and Public Sector TOTAL Compensation, Including Benefits and Job Security

So now let's turn to the relative pay practices between employees who work in the private and public sectors, respectively. We'll take a crack at what's "fair" TOTAL COMPENSATION for employees, customers and taxpayers.

When the free market establishes pay levels, determining what's fair and affordable pay is relatively easy. The "invisible hand" of the market takes care of that. If we pay too much, we go broke. If we pay too little, nobody works for us.

It's the same thing for a self employed individual. His time is worth whatever someone else is willing to pay him for doing what he does. Is it fair for rock stars, actors and professional atheletes to make the kind of money they do? Absolutely. Otherwise the customers wouldn't agree to pay those sums to see them perform. To repeat, that's the "invisibile hand" of the free market at work.

But what about government employees who work in a monopoly? Or even private sector workers who are represented by unions? Well, their pay is obviously arbitrary and not market based --- perhaps arbitrarily low or perhaps arbitrarily high --- but nevertheless arbitrary. The market's role is at best indirect.

And that brings us to average pay. A long time ago, someone explained averages to me in the following manner . If there are two of us standing in a room and one stands aside while the other has one hand on a burning stove and one foot in a freezer, both may experience average temperatures, but they certainly don't feel the same way. Get the point?

Why do workers who toil for the monopolistic government get paid by averages based on the number of degrees awarded, length of service and so forth?  Because it's easier to do it that way, I suspect, even if it's totally unfair to the top performers and a wrongheaded negative performance subsidy for the low performers.

For Federal Workers, the Grass Isn't Greener in the Private Sector tackles the issue of relative pay 'fairness' in the public and private sectors, including teaching:

"If public employees are underpaid, they ought to get raises when they switch to the private sector. But they don't, and that fact is telling.

Debates over compensation for public employees have raged at all levels of government over the past few years. The Federal Salary Council, an official advisory body, claimed in October that federal employees are paid only 65 cents for each dollar earned by workers in comparable jobs outside the federal government.

Federal workers would seem to be drastically underpaid, based on the council's numbers. But what does it really mean for public employees to be "underpaid" or "overpaid"?

Here's one way to think about it: If a worker is overpaid, he'd probably receive lower pay from most other employers. Likewise, an underpaid worker should be able to get a raise by performing similar work for a different employer. . . .

Analyzing how salaries for the same workers change as they shift between jobs in the public and private sectors automatically controls for worker traits that aren't directly measured in most datasets – traits such as intelligence, motivation and creativity. Only the job changes in these comparisons; the worker stays the same.

The Census Bureau tracks tens of thousands of households over several years in its Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP). Many workers in these households switch jobs during this time, allowing us to observe how workers' salaries rise or fall as they change jobs.

So what can applying this job-switching test to the SIPP data tell us about public employee pay? Keep in mind that the Federal Salary Council's numbers imply that in taking a job outside government, the average federal employee would receive a staggering 54 percent increase in salary. In the real world, though, the data show that most federal workers looking to cash in by leaving will end up disappointed.

According to the SIPP data, the average federal worker shifting to a private job actually accepts a small salary reduction of around 3 percent. Similarly, private sector workers who move to federal jobs don't take a pay cut. They get a first-year raise averaging 9 percent, well above the raise other workers get when they switch jobs within the private sector.

In short, there's real-world evidence that federal salaries are at least equal to private-sector salaries for workers with the same skills.

Now consider the state and local levels. If any group of public workers is underpaid, conventional wisdom suggests it would be schoolteachers. . . .

Not so. Nationwide, non-teachers who move into teaching receive an average raise of around 8 percent, according to SIPP data, while teachers who leave the profession take an average salary cut of around 3 percent. . . .

Of course, it's possible that the public employees who move to the private sector are among the least-skilled workers, helping to explain why they don't receive big pay increases. Even if this is the case, however, it implies that the most skilled government workers don't require a salary increase -- since they don't leave their jobs in the first place. . . .

Importantly, none of the tracked changes in salary after job switches takes into account the job-to-job changes in fringe benefits. Most public employees have guaranteed pensions and retiree health coverage, both of which are increasingly rare in the private sector.

In a competitive labor market, superior benefits should allow governments to offer lower salaries while continuing to attract and retain employees. But the evidence indicates that government salaries alone are comparable to, and often more generous than, those in the private sector.

Many public employees honestly believe that they could earn much more in the private sector. As it happens, though, few actually do. With federal, state and local governments paying out almost $1.5 trillion in employee compensation in 2012, this isn't a trivial fact."

Summing Up

When markets set pay, there's automatic "fairness."  Accordingly, when governments arbitrarily establish pay levels, there's no such objective "market check" on the pay scales.

And when public employees enjoy greater job security and more generous benefits than do their private sector counterparts, logic dictates that their direct compensation should be markedly lower than what's being paid for comparable work in the private sector.

But that's not what's happening. In fact, that's almost always not the case.

My take is that the pay and benefit levels for public workers should be set at much lower rates than that enjoyed by their private sector counterparts.

Then if the taxpayer supported public employee isn't satisfied with his pay level, let him enter the free market. And if a whole bunch of public employees immediately bolt for the private sector, then the taxpayer can be expected to willingly adjust public sector pay levels upward. If not, all's well.

It could be that simple, my fellow taxpayers. But the public sector unions and lots of government officials wouldn't like such a common sense approach one little bit.

Maybe that in itself makes it a very good idea and one worth trying.

Thanks. Bob.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Wal-Mart ... Sales are Tough Sledding ... Dividend Increased by 18%

The U.S. economy is soft, jobs are tough, gasoline prices are rising and the payroll tax burden has increased. Lots of "headwinds" out there for companies like Wal-Mart.

Yet Wal-Mart also announced an 18% increase in its annual dividend today. It has increased its dividend each year since 1974.

Accordingly, the yield is now over 2.5% compared to a yield on 10 year government bonds of roughly 2%.

Its shares are up more than 2% today at ~$71.

And by the way, Wal-mart's earnings are expected to grow again this year, as they seem to do every year, thus providing a solid backdrop for future share price appreciation and continuing annual dividend increases. Its annual sales are approaching $500 billion. What's not to like for long term investors?

Wal-Mart Expects Flat Sales This Quarter says this about the company's results and prospects:

"The world's largest retailer forecast flat same-store sales for its U.S. division in the current quarter, reflecting the strain its customers are under. Wal-Mart's core customer generally has a low income and is grappling with higher payroll taxes, rising gasoline prices and delayed income-tax refunds. The latter was in large part why February started out sluggishly, Wal-Mart U.S. Chief Executive Bill Simon said on a conference call. At this time last year, Wal-Mart had cashed $4 billion in tax refund and refund anticipation checks, Mr. Simon said. Currently it has cashed less than half of that, or $1.7 billion. Some of that money is typically earmarked around Super Bowl time for television sets. Now, the retailer doesn't know how the money will be spent. As a result, Wal-Mart is changing its merchandise a bit, going with smaller packaging and less expensive products, Mr. Simon said.

Regarding the payroll tax increase, "Customers know about it and are adjusting to it," Chief Financial Officer Charles Holley said. "It will become clearer as we move later into the year."

Business is perking up a bit at the retailer's largest unit. "We began seeing increased tax-refund-check activity last week in our stores," Mr. Simon said. "This resulted in a more normalized sales pattern for this time of the year."

Still, Wal-Mart remains challenged. "Jobs remain the top of the list and gas prices are making their way up," Mr. Simon said. . . .

As for Wal-Mart's results, "It's tough out there; the consumer is not spending," said Brian Yarbrough, retail analyst at Edward Jones. "So Wal-Mart has it tough, if not even tougher, than other retailers because their customers are low-income."

Wal-Mart forecast current-quarter earnings of $1.11 to $1.16 a share and estimated fiscal 2014 earnings at $5.20 to $5.40 a share. Analysts surveyed by Thomson Reuters expect $1.18 and $5.37, respectively. . . .

Wal-Mart also announced last month it was pushing further into the eye-care market by selling contact lenses online and by phone, and said it planned to launch its own private Equate brand of contact lenses in February.

On Thursday, the company said its board raised its annual dividend by 18% to $1.88 from $1.59, marking one of the largest increases in its history. Wal-Mart has increased its dividend every year since 1974. . . .

"We know there are challenges ahead, but we believe our strong financial position, along with our [everyday low cost] and [everyday low price] operating model, will continue to produce strong sales and returns for our shareholders," Mr. Holley said. . . .

For the current quarter, Wal-Mart said it expects flat U.S. same-store sales as rising fuel prices, changes in inflation and the payroll tax increase have slowed sales in the first few weeks of this year."

Summing Up

To repeat, times are tough.

That said, Wal-Mart is an extremely well managed company with a solid past and a bright future as well.

When the economy gathers steam down the road, which it will, Wal-Mart is well poisitioned to participate in that growth. 

In the meantime, it will continue to do well despite the difficult times ahead for the world's economies.

Again, what's not to like about Wal-Mart?

Thanks. Bob.

Unemployment to Stay High for a Long Time ... Health Care Jobs Account for All Jobs Created Since 2000

The politicians continue to 'feel our pain' and assure us that they intend to make us feel better by creating jobs and economic growth.

Just how they will accomplish that fete nobody knows and certainly not the political aristocrats. They're too busy fighting among themselves and calling each other names. Meanwhile, the economy remains stagnant and job growth remains elusive.

As a matter of fact, their political posturing, name calling and do nothingness will only result in more deficits and debt accumulation accompanied by weak economic growth as far as the eye can see. And perhaps surprisingly, at least to some people, we've experienced nothingless in the way of real job growth for more than a decade now.

Here are a few facts that you may find interesting. Whether what they reveal is a good or bad thing, I'll let you decide. That said, my guess is you'll be at least a little surprised about where all the U.S. job growth has come from since the year 2000.

My judgment says that this surprise isn't a pleasant one, but you can judge for yourself.

We need more jobs in America, of course, but is it really a good thing for all the nation's job growth this century to have come from the already inefficient, unaffordable and far too expensive U.S. health care sector? I think not.

Health Care Aside, Fewer Jobs Than in 2000 presents the facts:

"(Here's) one other important accomplishment of the much-maligned health care industry. Not only has it added more jobs than any other sector, but without it, there would actually be slightly fewer jobs in the United States today than in 2000.

In 2000, the economy had about 121 million non-health-care payroll jobs. Today, on a seasonally adjusted basis, there are 120 million non-health-care jobs. Meanwhile, the health care industry has added about 3.6 million jobs in that time frame, growing about 33 percent (14.5 million health care jobs today versus 10.9 million in 2000).
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, via Haver Analytics. January 2013 figures are seasonally adjusted; 2000 figures are annual numbers.
There have been times since 2000 that the country has had more non-health-care jobs on net than it had at the turn of the millennium, but that has not been true since late 2008. Here’s a look at the longer-term monthly numbers. Note that the vertical axis does not go down to zero to better show the change:
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, via Haver Analytics. Note that the vertical axis does not start at zero, better showing the change over time. 
Is it a good thing that the health care industry has been basically keeping the job market afloat? That depends on your perspective.

Health care is a notoriously inefficient industry — in 2008, there were five people performing administrative support for every one doctor — and a lot of the jobs that have been created in recent years probably involve feeding that inefficiency.

Market pressures don’t force streamlining in health care the way they do in other industries. That’s partly because of the way Americans pay for health care and the way the government subsidizes health care consumption. It’s also partly because health care is relatively shielded from international competition, since many medical services are difficult to offshore. It’s hard to have someone draw your blood from India, for example.

In any case, given how weak the economy is right now, it seems unlikely that the health care industry is snatching many workers away from other industries where their skills would be put to more productive use."

Summing Up

Health care employment, government employment and private sector wealth creating employment are three entirely different things with three entirely different impacts on our economy.

All mean jobs, but only private sector non-health care job growth results in meaningful and lasting employment which will result in a stronger national economy.

The conclusion is sad but simple. More government jobs and more health care workers relative to private sector jobs and workers will only make us weaker as a nation and more financially burdened as well.

That's my take. What's yours?

Thanks. Bob.





Detroit is Broke ... Not Saved ... What's Next? ... Who Knows?

We must begin to emphasize the fundamental national need for private sector led growth.

Otherwise, our deficits and growing national debts and unfunded entitlement obligations will continue uninterrupted and out of control. We also need to curtail unnecessary government spending and increase tax revenues. Doing these three things are absolute essentials to our nation's and citizens' future well being.

And without taking these actions, our growing financial problems as a society will get worse and worse until they are "unfixable" short of catastrophe. That much is clear.

Meanwhile, President Obama, our "Progressive-in-Chief," has pronounced GM to be among the saved. Detroit is GM's headquarters, so one would assume that if GM is saved, then its hometown would be safe. And Detroit serves as UAW headquarters as well, so I guess that makes the auto workers' union a viable institution, too. Or does it?

Is it too late for the city of Detroit to escape financial disaster? Maybe it is. And if so, shouldn't other cities try to learn its lessons before reaching a similar state of "unfixability?" Let's look closer.

GM and the UAW have been bailed out, at least temporarily, by the nation's taxpayers. Is it now the city of Detroit's turn? And if so, where will the taxpayers get the money? How much does the "Progressive-in-Chief" have left to spend?

Well, my guess is that nobody will ride to the rescue of Detroit anytime soon, if ever. It wouldn't be the politically smart thing to do, and it wouldn't accomplish anything useful either.

In fact, Detroit is perhaps in the worst shape of all American cities. What can be done is the question, and my guess is that nobody, including the President has the slightest idea of what the answer to the city's financial woes might be. The city may well be too far gone to be savable.

Detroit S.O.S. has the story:

"News flash: President Obama did not save Detroit. That's not actually news, at least not to Motown's 700,000 residents, but it may bear repeating as the president preaches his gospel of wealth and virtues of "collective action."

A report yesterday by a state-appointed financial review team indicates the city of Detroit may need to be put into conservatorship, an outcome Mayor Dave Bing and Gov. Rick Snyder had hoped to avoid last spring with a consent agreement. In return for $137 million in financial assistance, city leaders promised to undertake labor and other structural reforms.
image 
Dave Bing, mayor of Detroit

The review team now says the reforms city leaders have implemented are too little, too late, and that more drastic measures are required. Notwithstanding last year's state bailout, the city is facing a deficit of more than $100 million. The city has also accrued $15 billion in long-term liabilities (which includes retirement benefits) and will need to spend nearly $2 billion in the next five years to finance these debts.

Mr. Snyder has resisted appointing an emergency financial manager who would supercede Mr. Bing and the city council, but the review team suggests that doing so may be the only way to dig Motown out of its ditch. "We gave the city every chance to avoid the outcome we're recommending to the governor today," said state Treasurer Andy Dillon, who sat on the review team. Trouble is, city leaders have refused to take action.

Another option for the governor would be to allow the city to file for Chapter 9 bankruptcy, which would help shed much of its bond debt. But a court-mediated restructuring has significant downsides. For one, it would impair Detroit's ability to borrow for perhaps decades....

Nor would it necessarily force labor reforms since the U.S. Treasury Secretary would be authorized under federal bankruptcy law to intervene. That could result in a reprise of the Chrysler-United Auto Workers bailout.

Detroit needs to eliminate inefficiencies, slash labor costs and develop a growth strategy, all of which can be done outside of bankruptcy. It's too bad its political leaders haven't been up to the task."

Summing Up

Sadly, Detroit's story is not an unfamiliar one. And it won't be the last such story.

Cities are broke, states are broke and the U.S. as a whole has huge financial problems as well.

Meanwhile, the governments keep spending money we don't have on things we can't afford.

And We the People sit by and continue to let the political aristocrats practice their short term focused, sound bite based and vote getting political redistribution business as usual.

And perhaps as a nation we'll keep on keeping on avoiding the ugly reality until we no longer can look the other way. But not the citizens of Detroit. Their time has finally come when they must face the facts and deal with the truth.

And they'll learn that there's no easy way out. Maybe there's not even a hard way out of the mess they're in.

But gutting up and facing reality is going to be coming to lots of places real soon, and that's maybe a good thing.

That's my take.

Thanks. Bob.

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Work Place Discrimination, Profit Maximization and in College, the Effects of Student Grants v. Loans? ... Food for Thought

A brilliant economist died Tuesday at age 98. Most people had never heard of him.

So let's tell his story today.

Economist Armen Alchian said something quite meaningful about the difference between discrimination in the unregulated and heavily regulated private sector work places, respectively, as well as the profound difference between student grants and loans for college attendees.

His unconventional but highly logical view was that work place discrimination in regulated industries is more prevalent than other private sector companies and that student grants are inappropriate and unintended contributors to increasing income and wealth inequalities in society.

What he had to say was both logical and thought provoking, and therefore worth taking a few minutes to consider.

An Economist Who Made the Science Less Dismal in part contains what he had to say about work place discrimination as well as the 'fairness' of college tuition subsidies:

"Alchian also used the analysis of property rights to explain racial and ethnic discrimination. In a 1962 paper coauthored with the late University of Chicago economist Reuben Kessel, Alchian—himself subject to anti-Armenian discrimination early in his life—pointed out that discrimination was more pervasive in private firms whose profits were regulated by the government. Alchian and Kessel explained that discrimination is costly, not just to those discriminated against, but also to those who discriminate. The discriminators give up the chance to deal with someone with whom they could engage in mutually beneficial exchange.

Therefore, argued Alchian and Kessel, discrimination would be more prevalent in situations where those who discriminate don't bear much of the cost from doing so. A company whose profits are not regulated would see the cost of discrimination in the form of lower profits. A company whose profits were limited and that was already at the limit would face no cost from discriminating.

Alchian's first major article, "Uncertainty, Evolution and Economic Theory," was published in 1950. It was his response to a controversy about whether companies really do maximize profits. Alchian argued that even though all companies may not maximize profits, those that survive will be ones whose managers, by luck or design, came close to maximizing profits. Therefore, those that we observe will have maximized profits. So, for the long term at least, Alchian argued that economists don't need to show that all companies try to maximize profits in order to derive the standard conclusions from the profit-maximization assumption.

My personal favorite of his published papers is "The Economic and Social Impact of Free Tuition" (1968). Alchian pointed out that government aid to higher education is a transfer to the relatively rich. . . .

He compared subsidizing college to subsidizing drilling expenses for someone sitting on a large pool of oil. The untapped student's potential is the analogue of the untapped oil. Alchian argued that lack of current income might be a justification for loans to aspiring college students but not for outright subsidies. He cinched the argument with the following story:

One poor, "uneducated" resident of Watts, upon hearing Ralph Bunche [a well-known black educator and diplomat] say that he could not have had a college education unless tuition were free, opined, "Perhaps it's time to repay out of his higher income for that privilege granted him by taxes on us Negroes who never went to college."

I still make Alchian's point in my classes and, although it upsets my students, not a single one has been able to undercut the fundamental soundness of Alchian's argument."

Summing Up

Just like a sports team that plays the best players who can help the team win, private sector employers have every reason not to discrminate in their hiring and promotional policies. That's not the case with heavily regulated companies whose profits and success are largely controlled by government.

But the best example is that of granting tuition subsidies to college students. All those citizens who don't attend college are in effect subsidizing those who do and contributing to future income inequality in America.

I wonder what the "progressives" have to say about that.

RIP, Mr. Alchian.

Thanks. Bob.

President Obama is Either Confused, Mistaken or ... Maybe He's Just Lying About the Solution to the Nation's Fiscal Deficits ... Truth Telling's Time Has Come

In his State of the Union address last week, President Obama stated that we're 'more than halfway' on the road to a solution dealing with our nation's ongoing fiscal deficits and rapidly accumulating debt problems. Well, he's either confused, mistaken or lying about that 'more than halfway' conclusion.

In fact, what he's saying sounds a whole lot to me like he's practicing a future version of speaking Greek -- I guess he figures he might as well since he's guiding the U.S. down the path to bankrupt Greece -- with lots of help from the Congress, of course.

Ditto for the entirely political vote getting 'solution' of getting the rich to pay their 'fair share' in taxes as a remedy for our nation's financial mess. That won't do it either. It's just populist progressive political happy talk and there's no genuine substance to it. None at all.

As a nation, we're whistling past the "debt yard," and our "Progressive-in-Chief" president doesn't help matters at all when he repeatedly tells untruths to We the People. And not only because he's confused, mistaken or lying to us, but more important, some people actually believe what he's saying. And even though we'd all like to see the solution to fixing our financial woes be that easy and not involve pain for the non-rich bulk of voters, the 'middle class' and the oldsters, the remedy to our nation's financial troubles won't be an easy one. Not even close to being easy, as a matter of fact.

It's time to tell the truth and reverse course. While there's still plenty of time to do so. Besides, who wants our kids and grandkids to have to learn and speak Greek?

Next Stop, Greece is subtitled 'Debt Crisis: If we fail to rein in spending and increase taxes -- starting now -- the U.S. in 22 years could be in worse shape than Greece is today:'

"In his State of the Union speech last Tuesday, President Obama concluded that "the State of our Union is stronger." The big question is: stronger than what? . . .

According to estimates by the Congressional Budget Office, adjusted by Barron's to account for recent tax increases and other factors, if the U.S. doesn't raise taxes further and cut spending dramatically, the national debt could easily reach 153% of economic output by 2035. {NOTE: That's where Greece is today.}

These are not just numbers. If the U.S. national debt continues ballooning, we can be sure of a deep, long-lasting recession -- very likely a depression -- sometime in the next two to three decades. The unemployment rate could easily surge to 20%. . . .
 
This problem can't be solved by asking the rich to pay a little more, despite what the president says. In fact, Barron's calculates that immediately increasing the marginal tax rate to 50% on the top 1% of the country's earners would bring in $500 billion over the next 10 years. This would barely dent the country's debt load, which would then be $20 trillion, and do little to forestall a financial crisis.

 Getting the national debt under control will require tax increases for everyone, as well as budget cuts, particularly in entitlement spending, which is beginning to run out of control as the baby boomers hit retirement age. . . .
 
One key driver of this crisis scenario is inevitable: the aging of the baby boomers. As the chart shows, the rise in the share of the population 65 and over -- the age of eligibility for Medicare -- has just begun. Born from 1946 through 1964, the boomers will range in age from 49 to 67 this year. As they continue to age, the over-65 portion of the population, now 14.1%, will gradually climb, exceeding 20% for the first time in 2029, when the youngest boomers, born in 1964, will be turning 65.

Not coincidentally, around 2029 the ratio of U.S. government debt to annual economic output, or gross domestic product, will begin to exceed its peak of 112.7%, set in 1945, the final year of World War II. The difference, however, is that, with a major war concluded, the expectation then was that U.S. indebtedness would decline. Indeed, by 1955, the ratio had plummeted to 55.5%. In 2029, in contrast, the expectation will be for indebtedness to continue to explode.
 
image
The connection between the baby-boomer time bomb and the rising debt-to-GDP ratio reveals that the next 10 years, for all their potential difficulty, are actually the relative calm before the coming storm. And yet the 10-year outlook has framed the current discussion of the debt in Washington. . . .

The CBO added that, "Unless the laws governing those programs are changed -- or the increased spending is accompanied by corresponding reductions in other spending, sufficiently higher tax revenues, or a combination of the two -- debt will rise sharply, relative to GDP, after 2023.". . .

In his State of the Union address, the president claimed that efforts to tame debt and deficits had already progressed "more than halfway." In his view, then, all that remains to be done is to duplicate what has been done so far. Our assumptions easily accommodate that; in fact, the second and third scenarios, which factor in tax increases, exceed what has been done so far by a wide margin. Yet in all three cases, the long-term trajectory is still daunting. {NOTE: Translation is that president Obama is feeding us crapola.} . . .

Unless President Obama proposes drastic spending cuts, his vision for America requires imposing crippling taxes on the very people whose continued prosperity he so strongly champions -- the lower 99%. Even a 25% tax hike on this broad group wouldn't be enough to solve the budget problem unless it was combined with sharp cuts in spending.

Once this becomes clear, things could get ugly. "If the United States encountered a fiscal crisis," observed the CBO in its July 2010 Issue Brief, "the abrupt rise in interest rates would reflect investors' fears that the government would renege on the terms of its existing debt or that it would increase the supply of money to finance its activities or pay creditors and thereby boost inflation."

Add to that nightmare scenario the risk that Uncle Sam would have to renege on promises made to people over 65."

Summing Up

While the well researched study, which is this week's cover story in Barron's, is admittedly a bit deep in numbers and assumptions, it's definitely worth taking the time to read in its entirety.

Our nation's future well being is too important to leave to the short term oriented populist progressive politicians to decide.

The truth is the truth, the facts are the facts, our children's and grandchildren's futures are in our hands, and We the People simply aren't being told the truth about the perilous nature of our nation's fiscal condition and where, left uncorrected, it will inevitably lead America.

All that simply means that now more than ever, it's necessary for us to "seek and tell the truth" to ourselves and each other.

This issue is too important to the well being of future generations of Americans for us to continue the now well entrenched twin practices of can kicking and smoke and mirrors budgeting.

This shameful approach by our nation's politicians can't be allowed to continue.

It's not "fair" of us to let them do so. Not to the poor, not to the middle class and certainly not to future generations of Americans. And not to us oldsters either.

That's my take.

Thanks. Bob.

 


 





Tuesday, February 19, 2013

NEW BUDGET PROPOSAL TO BE RELEASED TODAY ... Sticking It to the Younger Folks Needs To STOP

We oldsters are quite unintentionally sticking it to the younger folks. That's unfair and it has to stop.

Today the fourth attempt by Simpson-Bowles, a bipartisan budget reducing commission established by President Obama several years ago, will make an attempt to get Congress and the White House to be serious about getting our nation's financial affairs in order and our deficits, debt and underfunded entitlement programs under control. It has to happen sometime, so why not  now?

Simpson and Bowles to Offer Up Deficit Fix says this in part:

"Deficit hawks Alan Simpson and Erskine Bowles on Tuesday will propose a detailed plan for rewriting the tax code and implementing deep new spending cuts, hoping to offer a path to compromise for Democrats and Republicans, according to an outline of the plan.
image
Erskine Bowles, right, and Alan Simpson spoke outside the White House in Washington D.C. on April 14, 2011, after a meeting with President Barack Obama.

Messrs. Simpson and Bowles co-chaired the White House's 2010 deficit-reduction panel, which put together a bipartisan package of tax and spending changes that fell flat after the administration and congressional leaders took a look. . . .

Mr. Simpson, a Republican, and Mr. Bowles, a Democrat, say their new proposal would reduce the federal budget deficit by $2.4 trillion over 10 years, more than the $1.5 trillion package that White House officials have said is their goal. Obama administration officials say any deficit-reduction package must include new tax revenue as well as spending cuts.

House GOP leaders have not yet detailed the size of the deficit-reduction package they will propose, but they have said it would balance the budget within 10 years, which would put it in the $4 trillion range. They have said, though, that it won't include any tax increases.

The new $2.4 trillion Simpson-Bowles proposal would identify $600 billion in spending reductions through changes to health-care programs such as Medicare and Medicaid. That is roughly $200 billion more than the White House has said it is willing to accept. . . .

Another $600 billion in deficit-reduction would come from curbing or ending a number of tax breaks. This is about in line with the level of increased revenue White House officials have said they are seeking, but most Republicans have said they won't accept any tax increases as part of a deficit-reduction package.

The final $1.2 trillion in the proposal would come from lower caps on discretionary spending—the type Congress approves annually—changing the way cost-of-living increases are calculated for Social Security checks and other government benefits, cuts to farm subsidies, and changes to military and civilian retirement programs, among other things.

The package marks at least the fourth effort by Messrs. Simpson and Bowles in the past three years to galvanize public and political backing for a deficit-reduction deal."

.......................................................................................

MY SIMPLE NON-POLITICAL TAKE ON ALL THIS

The biggest problem facing America today isn't about the rich denying money to help the middle class or government programs which are spending too much money on helping the poor.

The biggest problem, my friends, is the old stealing future oportunities from the young. We have piled on too much debt, too much government spending, too many unfunded entitlements and too little economic growth for them to be able to continue to support us in the style to which we think we're 'entitled.'

And at the same we've saddled them with a too expensive and poor educational system of public education, including college. And lest I forget, lots of burdensome student loans and no good job prospects either.

In my view, saving the middle class means saving ourselves from ourselves, first and foremost. Pogo said it best, "We have met the enemy and he is us."

Generational Theft Needs to be Arrested tells the true story in clear and convincing fashion:

image
"Government spending levels are unsustainable. Higher taxes, however advisable or not, fail to come close to solving the problem. Discretionary spending must be reduced but without harming the safety net for our most vulnerable, or sacrificing future growth (e.g., research and education). Defense and homeland security spending should not be immune to reductions. Most consequentially, the growth in spending on entitlement programs—Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare—must be curbed.

These truths are not born of some zeal for austerity or unkindness, but of arithmetic. The growing debt burden threatens to crush the next generation of Americans.

Coming out of the most recent elections, no consensus emerged either to reform the welfare state or to pay for it. And too many politicians appear unwilling to level with Americans about the challenges and choices confronting the United States. The failure to be forthright on fiscal policy is doing grievous harm to the country's long-term growth prospects. And the greatest casualties will be young Americans of all stripes who want—and need—an opportunity to succeed.

Three main infirmities plague Washington and constitute a clear and present danger to the prospects for the next generation.

First, the country's existing entitlement programs are not just unaffordable, they are also profoundly unfair to those who are taking their first steps in search of opportunity. Social Security is one example. According to Social Security actuaries, the generational theft runs deep. Young people now entering the workforce will actually lose 4.2% of their total lifetime wages because of their participation in Social Security. A typical third-grader will get back (in present value terms) only 75 cents for every dollar he contributes to Social Security over his lifetime. Meanwhile, many seniors with greater means nearing retirement age will pocket a handsome profit. Health-care spending through Medicare represents an even less equitable story.

The government has an obligation, of course, to support needy seniors. But this pension system is ripe for common-sense reforms, including changing eligibility ages and benefit structures for those with greater means, ridding the Social Security disability program of pervasive fraud, and removing disincentives for those who would rather work in their later years.

Powerful, vested interests portray reformers as avowed enemies of seniors. But, the status quo is, in fact, tantamount to saddling school-age children with more debt, weaker economic growth, and fewer opportunities for jobs and advancement.

Second, while many in Washington pay lip service to the long term, few act on it. The nation's debt clock garners far less attention than the "fiscal cliff" clock. Elected officials continue to allow the immediate to trump the important. . . .

In successive administrations, the country has spent trillions in temporary tax credits and short-term "stimulus" to goose growth by the next election. What do we have to show for this spending surge? Modest growth, declining incomes and a level of national debt that undermine our long-term prospects. . . .

But the deeper failing is one of essential fairness. . . . And failing to deal with runaway spending will burden the country's children with higher interest rates and a debt bomb that will come due in their lifetimes.

Third, too many politicians appear more eager to divide the spoils of electoral victory among their own than to increase the size of the economic pie for all. The grab-bag of special tax favors under the guise of the recent fiscal-cliff deal is only the latest example.

Crony capitalism and corporate welfare aren't just expenses we cannot afford. They are an anathema to economic growth. They deny opportunities to aspiring people and companies who seek to better their lot. They ration opportunity based on things other than merit and hard work. They further ensure that poor children—who already are disadvantaged by failing schools, inadequate health care and little access to necessary resources—will never get the chance to break the cycle of generational poverty through education.

Some individual Americans are surely better off than they were many years ago. The more probing question is whether America is better off. That can only be true if the hopes and aspirations of the next generation are achievable.

The country must find the courage, conviction and compassion to fix what ails it. The opportunity to advance real reform is still possible. But failure to reform the entitlement culture, reaffirm long-run objectives, and re-establish a common purpose will mean a dimming of opportunities for American children today and for future generations. And a great nation will have ceded more than its greatness, but its goodness."

Summing Up

Facts are facts, the truth is the truth and the future will be whatever we make it to be.

It's up to us.

There is no time or reason to assign blame for how we arrived at our present place in time or our currently unsustainable debt and deficits, combined with a lousy economy and a lousy system of government run public education and health care.

We are where we are, but we need not stay where we are.

We need to start telling the truth to each other, and the truth is that the government is too big and spending too much money on the oldsters.

The truth also is that self reliance in America needs renewed emphasis and encouragement, as does the value of education and knowledge.

We have to change a lot of things, including our politics, if we are going to maintain our heritage as the single best place on earth to live, get an educaiton, work and raise a family.

That's my take.

Thanks. Bob.

Monday, February 18, 2013

Keystone Pipeline Decision ... Which Way Will It Go?

President Obama is faced with a big time POLITICAL decision about North American energy independence, jobs, economic growth and our future relations with Canada, our close neighbor and ally.

Both labor unions and businesses support the Keystone pipeline's construction, as do most Americans.

The greenies, aka environmentalists, oppose it.

Politically, both unions and environmentalists support Democrats. That puts President Obama between the proverbial political rock and a hard place.

All North Americans (U.S., Canadian and Mexican citizens alike) wish for energy independence. Achieving that happy state of affairs will enhance both our continent's and nation's security, economic growth and global competitiveness.

In addition, it will bring more jobs to unemployed Americans and billions of dollars in additional tax receipts to the U.S. Treasury, both of which are badly needed.

So watching what the President decides to do about Keystone will be both revealing and instructive as to how serious he is about growing the U.S. economy during his second term in office.

Let's hope the greenies have nothing to celebrate and that in the end the President does what's best for America.

Obama Faces Risks in Pipeline Decision covers the Keystone situation well:
A protest on Sunday against the Keystone oil pipeline, a project that Canada is counting on and that environmentalists oppose.
 
President Obama faces a knotty decision in whether to approve the much-delayed Keystone oil pipeline: a choice between alienating environmental advocates who overwhelmingly supported his candidacy or causing a deep and perhaps lasting rift with Canada.       

Canada, the United States’ most important trading partner and a close ally on Iran and Afghanistan, is counting on the pipeline to propel more growth in its oil patch, a vital engine for its economy. Its leaders have made it clear that an American rejection would be viewed as an unneighborly act and could bring retaliation. . . . 
 
But this is also a decisive moment for the United States environmental movement, which backed Mr. Obama strongly in the last two elections. For groups like the Sierra Club, permitting a pipeline carrying more than 700,000 barrels a day of Canadian crude into the country would be viewed as a betrayal, and as a contradiction of the president’s promises in his second inaugural and State of the Union addresses to make controlling climate change a top priority for his second term....      
 
Michael Brune, executive director of the Sierra Club, predicted that Mr. Obama would veto the $7 billion project because of the adverse effects development of the Canadian oil sands would have on the global climate.
 
“It’s rare that a president has such a singular voice on such a major policy decision,” Mr. Brune said. “Whatever damage approving the pipeline would do to the environmental movement pales in comparison to the damage it could do to his own legacy.”
 
Mr. Brune was one of about four dozen pipeline protesters arrested at the White House on Wednesday, in an act of civil disobedience that was a first for the 120-year-old Sierra Club.
 
So far, Mr. Obama has been able to balance his promises to promote both energy independence and environmental protection, by allowing more oil and gas drilling on public lands and offshore while also pushing auto companies to make their vehicles more efficient. But the Keystone decision, which is technically a State Department prerogative but will be decided by the president himself, defies easy compromise.
 
“This is a tricky political challenge for the president,” said Michael A. Levi, an energy fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. “The reality is everyone has defined the stakes on Keystone in such absolute terms that it is borderline impossible to see a compromise that will satisfy all the players.”
 
The proposed northern extension of the nearly 2,000-mile Keystone XL pipeline would connect Canada’s oil sands to refineries around Houston and the Gulf of Mexico, replacing Venezuelan heavy crude with similar Canadian grades.
 
Proponents say its approval would be an important step toward reducing reliance on the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries for energy. Opponents say that the expansion of oil production in shale fields across the country has already reduced the need for imports. Environmentalists have singled out the pipeline because it would carry oil derived from tar sands, in a process that is dirtier than other forms of oil production and that releases more carbon dioxide.
 
The State Department appeared poised to approve the pipeline in 2011, but Mr. Obama delayed a decision based on concerns about its route through vulnerable grasslands in Nebraska. The pipeline company, TransCanada, submitted a revised route, and the governor of Nebraska approved the plan last month, sending the final decision to Washington.
 
The Keystone pipeline is treated mainly as a domestic issue in Washington. But for Canada’s Conservative government, which has its power base in the oil-rich province of Alberta, it represents a crucial moment in Canada’s relationship with its most vital foreign partner even if the oil sands are also a divisive issue within Canada. Mr. Obama and Prime Minister Stephen Harper are not close . . . . While Mr. Obama comes from the liberal wing of his party . . ., Mr. Harper is conservative even by the standards of his own Conservative Party . . . . His political base, the province of Alberta, is the heart of the Canadian oil patch. . . . 
 
Still, the amount of Canadian oil that the United States imports daily — 2.4 million barrels, roughly twice what it imports from Saudi Arabia — points up a cornerstone of Mr. Obama’s goal to decrease dependence on oil from the unstable Middle East and unreliable sources like Venezuela. The Keystone pipeline would increase Canadian oil imports by more than 700,000 barrels a day, the equivalent of roughly two-thirds of Venezuelan imports.

 
Canadian leaders are cautious not to threaten the Obama administration directly, but they suggest that if the pipeline is not permitted, the close relationship between the countries will be damaged and Canada forced to look elsewhere, particularly to China, for new energy markets.
 
“The signal of a rejection of a permit by the president would be a significant change in the Canada-U.S. relationship,” said Greg Stringham, the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers’ vice president for oil sands and markets. “Canada, right now, with our potential growth in energy, is looking for security of demand wherever that might be throughout the world.” . . . 
 
Canada has powerful allies in the United States labor movement, which is pushing for the pipeline because proponents say it would generate tens of thousands of jobs, and in big oil companies like Exxon Mobil and Chevron that are heavily invested in the oil sands fields.
 
The rapid expansion of oil sands production has made oil critical to the Canadian economy. Canada has invested more than $100 billion in the oil sands over the last 10 years, shifting economic and political power westward to Alberta. Production is tied to 75,000 jobs nationwide, a number that is expected to multiply over the next 25 years, and nearly all of the country’s oil exports go to the United States.
 
The shortage of pipeline capacity has produced localized supply gluts, forcing the price of Canadian crude well below American and international benchmarks. If the Keystone pipeline is not completed, energy experts say, weak prices will make the economics of future oil sands projects questionable.
 
The Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers estimates that the country’s current production of 3.2 million barrels of oil a day will reach 6.2 million barrels a day by 2030, with oil sands representing an overwhelming share of the increase.
 
The producers and Canadian officials insist that more Canadian oil will reach United States markets one way or another, even if the Keystone project is not approved — most likely through a combination of rail, barges, trucks and pipelines once used to transport natural gas."
 
Summing Up
 
Business and labor agree with most Canadians and most Americans. We need the Keystone pipeline to be approved and built asap, if not sooner.
 
But that's been the case for several years now.
 
Will the President do the right thing for the future of our national security, the U.S. domestic economy and the well being of the Canadian economy?
 
That's the question. We'll eagerly await the answer as presidential can kicking is about over on this one.
 
It's time to bite the bullet.
 
Thanks. Bob.